Just a little over 24 hours ago, BGR secured themselves a Palm Pre and promised a full review was forthcoming. Today BGR delivered on their promise offering up a comprehensive review of the Palm Pre. Here are a few select snippets from BGR's review. Visit their site for the complete review, complete with photos.
The screen is where the Palm Pre shines. Selections take little to no effort and there’s that oh-so-magical water ripple effect when actually touching the display. It’s vibrant, rich and all around really clear.
Keyboard: It’s really not good. You can’t compete with RIM in the keyboard area and you can’t compete with Apple in the soft-keyboard area, so how are people going to enjoy using your product when the data entry isn’t perfection?
It’s fits perfectly in your hand and Palm did a great job blending an awesome touchscreen with a separate multi-touch gesture area, sliding design, and everything else together in this package.
To be honest, the device feels a little cheap. The edges of the bottom piece are sharp on the back of the screen and even worse, when sliding it up and down, the top part that houses the screen will sometimes catch on itself.
ake that for what you will but we don’t see a problem with Palm’s quoted battery life and from other reports, the battery is a pretty decent at keeping you going throughout the day.
The browser for the most part renders pages properly and pretty quickly.
Overall, they seem pleased with the Pre calling the OS great.
Comments (20)
written by waldoppper, May 29, 2009
written by seraphemz, May 29, 2009
Do you acknowledge that one Chris?
IMO... it was lame. Just wondering what you thought.
written by Agent K, May 29, 2009
written by PreRocks, May 29, 2009
It is quite comprehensive!
written by Agent K, May 29, 2009
written by seraphemz, May 29, 2009
PS.. Gemma Atkinson....gigggiitty giggitty. I never even heard of her before. Thanks for the pics.
written by Danny99000, May 29, 2009
@Agent K,
No word on anything of substance regarding the OS! He spent more words talking about app development on the phone compared to the 1st gen iPhone than the OS itself. Pathetic!
written by hopper84, May 29, 2009
written by Dirk Belligerent, May 29, 2009
The review boils down to this: "Screen is beautiful, but not as good as the iPhone. It's really small and light and thus doesn't feel as quality as the iPhone. The keyboard doesn't suit us; the iPhone's virtual keyboard is better. Most of the multimedia doesn't work yet and we don't know if anyone will be able to match the iPhone's awesomeness."
Yeah, that's useful. See the tilt?
In the comments (around 100 in), they admitted, "It’s not our fault Palm/Sprint didn’t send us a final review unit. We managed to get our hands on one, and whatever it was, it was. This is the most recent available OS as far as we’re aware."
"[W]hatever it was, it was"?!?! WTF is that?!?!? That'd be like Roger Ebert reviewing the leaked Wolverine workprint and complaining about how poor the FX were. These guys are clowns. Save your clicks.
written by sonisoe, May 29, 2009
written by dragonol2, May 30, 2009



I'm also extremely disappointed BGR decided to gloss over some of the features of WebOS that have everyone excited in the first place. Yes they talk about Synergy, but what about true and easy to manage (via the card metaphor) multi-tasking and intrusive notifications? These are big deals and hardly mentioned, if at all. You don't skip over major features in a review.
I'll give them their criticisms of the hardware's build quality, but I would have liked them to spend more then a day with the keyboard before calling it a failure. Hardware keyboards can sometimes take a little time to get used to.
As for the unit resetting itself on them, well again that's why you DO NOT review pre-release software. Until we hear about that happening to people on their brand new Pre's fresh out of a box from the SPRINT store it is not an issue.
Overall very disappointed in BGR and I can see why some of the bigger tech blogs such as Endgadget and Gizmodo have not reported on their preview/review yet.